Minnesota Historical Society M-Flame Logo

 Back to top

Execution of William Williams, 1906

Creator: 
  • Cite
  • Share
  • Correct
  • Comment
  • Print
William Williams in the county jail, 1905

Photograph of William Williams. Williams was tried, convicted, and executed for killing his estranged lover, Johnny Keller, and Johnny’s mother Mary. Photo taken by a St. Paul Dispatch photographer in the county jail on April 13, 1905. Image reproduced from microfilm at the Minnesota Historical Society with permission from the St. Paul Pioneer Press.

On February 13, 1906, the state of Minnesota executed William Williams for murdering his lover. When his hanging went awry, newspapers broke state law to report the graphic story. The botched Williams execution caused renewed fervor against the death penalty. Williams was the last person legally executed by the state, and capital punishment was formally repealed in 1911.

Ten months earlier, on April 12, 1905, Williams argued with sixteen year old Johnny Keller and his mother Mary at their St. Paul home. Williams shot them during the exchange; Johnny died within twenty-four hours, and his mother died after eight days. Williams turned himself in to the police immediately and confessed to the crimes.

During the winter and spring of that year, stories of murder splashed across the front pages of St. Paul newspapers. The trials of the two most sensational murderers, Edward Gottschalk and Williams, even overlapped by a day. Gottschalk was notorious because of the gruesome way he killed his victims, and because he committed suicide before he could be executed by the state. Williams's murders were intriguing to readers because of his history with the victims.

Williams, a steamfitter from Cornwall, England, had met Johnny Keller in 1903, when they were both hospitalized for diphtheria. They quickly developed a romantic relationship. After they were released from the hospital, Keller joined Williams as he traveled across Minnesota and Manitoba, Canada looking for work.

Intimate relationships between male laborers, including men of different ages, were not unusual in the early twentieth century. But when Williams tried to bring Keller with him to Winnipeg for a third time, Keller's parents became upset and Keller returned home to St. Paul. Williams had gone to St. Paul to confront them, but he swore that he did not mean to kill Johnny.

Williams used "emotional insanity" as his defense, saying that alcohol and an argument made him temporarily insane. After hearing readings of his intimate letters with Johnny Keller, including one where Williams threatened the boy, the court rejected this claim. The jury found Williams guilty of first degree murder, which meant that he would be executed.

Many Minnesotans were opposed to capital punishment at the turn of the twentieth century, but the state legislature was not able to repeal it. Governor John A. Johnson was against capital punishment but said he would enforce the law. Williams was set to be hanged on February 13, 1906. As required by the John Day Smith law, passed in 1889, his execution would happen in the middle of the night, with no journalists present.

The 1889 law, named after its sponsor, Representative John Day Smith, was passed because Minnesota had a long history of rowdy executions, including executions by lynch mobs that worked outside of the legal system. By suppressing information about executions, the Smith law was supposed to keep the public calm when executions occurred.

But when Williams's hanging was botched, the public did not stay calm. Ramsey County Sheriff Anton Miesen miscalculated how much rope was needed. The rope stretched, and Williams hit the floor of the courthouse basement without breaking his neck. Three deputies had to pull the rope up to strangle Williams. Fourteen and a half minutes later, Williams was pronounced dead.

Newspapers reported the event in spite of the Smith law. A reporter for the St. Paul Daily News snuck into the execution and witnessed it firsthand. The botched hanging was gruesome, and the public was sympathetic to Williams. His story of love and heartbreak had been relatable, and he was brave in his final days.

The resulting outcry led to the end of the death penalty five years later. After Williams's execution, consecutive Governors Johnson and A.O. Eberhart chose to commute all death sentences to life imprisonment. Also during that time, public opinion shifted: Minnesotans saw the death penalty as cruel following the Williams' execution, and they began to see it as ineffective at deterring crime. In 1911, Representative George MacKenzie authored a bill, signed by Governor Eberhart, which finally abolished the penalty altogether. Although extra-legal lynchings continued to occur until 1920, there were no more legal executions in Minnesota.

  • Cite
  • Share
  • Correct
  • Comment
  • Print
© Minnesota Historical Society
  • Bibliography
  • Related Resources

Anderson, Michael. "Minnesota's John Day Smith Law and the Death Penalty Debate." Minnesota History 58, no.2 (2002): 84–91.
http://collections.mnhs.org/MNHistoryMagazine/articles/58/v58i02p084-091.pdf

Bessler, John D. Legacy of Violence: Lynch Mobs and Executions in Minnesota. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 2003.

Murphy, Ryan Patrick and Alex T. Urquhart. "Sexuality in the Headlines: Intimate Upheavals as Histories of the Twin Cities." In Queer Twin Cities: Twin Cities GLBT Oral History Project, ed. Michael David Franklin, Larry Knopp, Kevin P. Murphy, Ryan Patrick Murphy, Jennifer L. Pierce, Jason Ruiz, and Alex T. Urquhart, 40-89. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 2010.

Tice, D. J. "The Last Hanging: The Gottschalk and Williams Murder Cases, 1905." In Minnesota's Twentieth Century: Stories of Extraordinary Everyday People, 11–17. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1999.

Trenerry, Walter N. Murder in Minnesota, a Collection of True Cases. St. Paul: Minnesota Historical Society Press, 1962.

Related Images

William Williams in the county jail, 1905
William Williams in the county jail, 1905
Fragment of rope which formed part of the noose used to hang William Willams
Fragment of rope which formed part of the noose used to hang William Willams

Turning Point

On February 13, 1906, the rope used to hang William Williams is the wrong length, and he is choked to death for nearly fifteen minutes. The grisly experience leads Minnesota to eliminate the death penalty in 1911.

Chronology

1889

The Minnesota State Legislature passes the John Day Smith Law, requiring state executions to happen in the middle of the night and banning press coverage.

1890

The Smith law is challenged but upheld by the U.S. Supreme Court.

1903

William Williams meets Johnny Keller in the hospital, and they develop a romantic relationship.

1904

Keller's family disapproves of his relationship with Williams; Keller travels with his older beau, but eventually returns home to St. Paul, Minnesota.

1905

In April, Williams fatally shoots Johnny Keller and his mother Mary; in May, Williams is tried, convicted, and sentenced to death for first-degree murder.

1906

On February 13, Williams is executed, but the rope used to hang him is too long. He is strangled by his executioners for nearly fifteen minutes, and newspapers break the law to report on the event.

1907

The Minnesota Supreme court upholds convictions against St. Paul newspapers for breaking the Smith law when they reported on Williams's execution.

1911

Governor Adolph O. Eberhart signs a law abolishing the state death penalty on April 22.









  

Comments

Correction to Related Resources: Primary. See below.

Case Files, Minnesota Supreme Court, 1850–1992
State Archives Collection, Minnesota Historical Society, St. Paul
Description: File number 14459 contains the full records of Williams's appeal to the Minnesota Supreme Court. The file includes briefs from the prosecution and defense, as well as materials like the grand jury indictment and court transcript that also appear in the Execution Records (see above). These files are stored off site and must be requested in advance.

Add to Related Resources: Primary.

Ramsey County Sheriff, Expense document concerning execution of William Williams, October 1906
State Archives Collection, Minnesota Historical Society, St. Paul
Description: Itemized and verified statement of expenses incurred in carrying out the February 1906 execution of William Williams, including the lumber and labor for constructing the gallows, clothing for the condemned man, and the rope. The document is signed by Ramsey County Sheriff Anton Miesen.

i was thankful i was able to read this very nice post about the life of William Williams , i don't know Williams then til i read this.. i like the whole story it a very nice story to tell..http://buildmydownloads.org/views/ purchase datpiff views

http://buildmylikes.org/followers/get instagram followers me too pamela hendricks i was glad i had the opportunity to know Williams and his story.. this was an interesting post.

Hey, Good Day! You have written a great article. I am happy to drop by and gain more information's about this article. increase soundcloud likes @ http://socialsoundcloud.org/buy-soundcloud-likes/

Awesome and interesting article. Great things you've always shared with us. Thanks. Just continue composing this kind of post.
http://www.irepliquemontresluxe.com

Thank you for this great information. You must have a tough research on this.
<a href="http://soundcloudexperts.com/buy-soundcloud-likes/">buy soundcloud likes</a>

Thanks for this informative article!
<a href="http://socialsoundcloud.org/">increase soundcloud services</a>

Every user is happy to use the best essay services and online www.best-dissertations.net essay writing services. So that, these are all helps to create best online writing services and content writing tips.

I really appreciate this wonderful post that you have provided for us.
I assure this would be beneficial for most of the people.
Looking forward to read more of your post and updates in the future.

http://socialsoundcloud.org

Justice has been served. Murdering someone for any reason is just wrong !

Buy soundcloud services - http://socialsoundcloud.org

We've must follow the geneva convention law for human rights...
<a href="http://socialsoundcloud.org/buy-soundcloud-plays/">increase soundcloud plays</a>

What is success? I think it is a mixture of having a flair for the thing that you are doing; knowing that it is not enough, that you have got to have hard work and a certain sense of purpose. http://volverconella.org

That was really great post for me thanks for sharing this. http://brokervergleicher.weebly.com/

The internet is bogged down with bogus blogs with no real message but the post was fantastic and well worth the read.Thank you for sharing this with me... http://www.sweetservices.com/

Fantastic work carried out right here. This really is exceptional. This is the most ideal publish that I've read in recent months. It fills me with great pleasure to read this. Maintain this work. http://www.benidormweekends.co.uk/

Superb! This really is a first class post. I've absolutely no issues from this post. You have composed a really elegant post here and I just wish that you'll keep doing that! https://www.rebelmouse.com/lovetractionlinesreviews/

You have a very inspiring way of exploring and sharing your thoughts. It is very uncommon nowadays, lots of sites and blogs having copy pasted or rewritten info. But here, no doubt, info is original and very well structured. Keep it up. http://japaneseculturelove.tumblr.com/

Thanks for making such a cool post which is really very well written.will be referring a lot of friends about this.Keep blogging. http://therapy-er.com/?p=35602

At one point I lost focus because it got a bit boring. I had to skip through the lines to reach the key point. I wanted to point out that if you don’t get to the point soon, people will stop reading it. You can work on that. Click here to discover some stylish and comfy outfits http://www.angeljackets.com/categories/Doctor-Who-Coat-Jacket/.

This is actually the content Now i'm searching for anywhere. Regards for use on your web page, I simply subscribe your blog. They can be a excellent web page. .
Blog commenting service
https://www.fiverr.com/seo_dj/give-you-great-offer-backlinks-50-pr2topr7-actual

I can say it is awesome, I am reading this article daily this is one of the big hits of the http://www.myessay.biz/editing/ good knowledge and thank you. It is very great to hear I am happy to learn more knowledge keep ti up in the same way.

Really important written content. the information that you shown is hard to faith and many superbly i liked the way you afford things here. http://memyfriends.com/

Keller in 1903, when they were both hospitalized for diphtheria. They quickly developed a romantic relationship. After they were released from the hospital, Keller joined Williams as he traveled across Minnesota and Manitoba, Canada looking for work.
https://www.rebelmouse.com/whatmensecretlywantreview/
tips to be irresistible to him

he trials of the two most sensational murderers, Edward Gottschalk and Williams, even overlapped by a day. Gottschalk was notorious because of the gruesome way he killed his victims,
http://www.designerkidsandbaby.co.uk
personalised gifts

Gottschalk was notorious because of the gruesome way he killed his victims, and because he committed suicide before he could be executed by the state. Williams's murders were intriguing to readers because of his history with the victims.
http://www.roketingilizce.com
ingilizce öğrenme seti

Samira Laser Clinic in Scarborough: Permanent Hair Removal for Men and Women
Samira Laser Clinic in Scarborough should be your only choice for laser hair removal. Our precision equipment carefully removes your hair while keeping your skin soft and glowing. We specialize in laser hair removal, facials and microdermabrasion. We also perform waxing and sell laser hair removal machines!
http://www.samiralaserclinic.com
laser clinic scarborough

I was exactly searching for. Thanks for such post and please keep it up. Great work...http://www.projectmudpuppy.com/getting-back-with-your-ex-is-it-even-a-good-idea/

I will be sure to bookmark it and return to read more of your useful information. Thanks for the post.
http://zammuamazingcashcrop.com/

Keller in 1903, when they were both hospitalized for diphtheria. They quickly developed a romantic relationship. After they were released from the hospital, Keller joined Williams as he traveled across Minnesota and Manitoba, Canada looking for work.
http://awesomebooking.com
cheap travel

Such a very useful article. Very interesting to read this article.I would like to thank you for the efforts you had made for writing this awesome article. http://www.erset.net/do-these-all-natural-cures-for-erectile-dysfunction-really-improve-sexual-performance/

I would like to say that this blog really convinced me to do it! Thanks, very good post. http://regvps.ru/windows-vps/

It is great and we ought to value it. It's difficult to sort the great from the awful basically, yet we know you've nailed it. www.kingofthieveshack.team9.org

The main purpose is for us to share our personal shopping experience and so we "the buyers" could establish a credible list of reliable websites http://www.starringsue.com

Hi buddy, your blog's design is simple and clean and i like it. Your blog posts are superb. Please keep them coming. Greets!!! http://www.snapmunk.com/

ottschalk was notorious because of the gruesome way he killed his victims, and because he committed suicide before he could be executed by the state. Williams's murders were intriguing to readers because of his history with the victims.
http://www.vbrservers.com.br/ 
hospedagem de sites

I am extremely awed with your web journal you made a hard showing. what's more,You have raised an imperative issue..Thanks for sharing..
<a href="http://www.my-cloud.net/">rent a web server</a>

The trials of the two most sensational murderers, Edward Gottschalk and Williams, even overlapped by a day. Gottschalk was notorious because of the gruesome way he killed his victims, and because he committed suicide before he could be executed by the state. Williams's murders were intriguing to readers because of his history with the victims.
http://www.moveontario.org/
movers

The trials of the two most sensational murderers, Edward Gottschalk and Williams, even overlapped by a day. Gottschalk was notorious because of the gruesome way he killed his victims, and because he committed suicide before he could be executed by the state. Williams's murders were intriguing to readers because of his history with the victims.
http://www.ciuohecampus.com/
online learning

Williams, a steamfitter from Cornwall, England, had met Johnny Keller in 1903, when they were both hospitalized for diphtheria. They quickly developed a romantic relationship. After they were released from the hospital, Keller joined Williams as he traveled across Minnesota and Manitoba, Canada looking for work.
http://authentichustle.com/
Hip Hop Entertainment

Such a very useful article. Very interesting to read this article.I would like to thank you for the efforts you had made for writing this awesome article.! http://www.mylimousines.ca/toronto/ontario/wedding/limousines/

I liked lesson your compositions. This is really a awesome comprehend for me. I possess bookmarked it besides I am looking relay to lesson unaccustomed storys. Holding foretell a join of your couriers, I can just discover persons who communicate endeavors. Nice post! This is a very nice blog that I will definitively come back to more times this year!
Please Visit Our Website Too!
<a href="http://geobintaro.com"><b>beli-geotextile-bintaro</b></a>

The trials of the two most sensational murderers, Edward Gottschalk and Williams, even overlapped by a day. Gottschalk was notorious because of the gruesome way he killed his victims, and because he committed suicide before he could be executed by the state. Williams's murders were intriguing to readers because of his history with the victims.
http://www.theairplaneman.com/
airplane

illiams tried to bring Keller with him to Winnipeg for a third time, Keller's parents became upset and Keller returned home to St. Paul. Williams had gone to St. Paul to confront them, but he swore that he did not mean to kill Johnny.
http://www.wockhardtfoundation.org
NGOs in India

This' a truly great article. I might want to welcome your work, Thanks for sharing!https://www.plurk.com/p/l5vz77
dragon city hack online

The trials of the two most sensational murderers, Edward Gottschalk and Williams, even overlapped by a day. Gottschalk was notorious because of the gruesome way he killed his victims, and because he committed suicide before he could be executed by the state. Williams's murders were intriguing to readers because of his history with the victims.
http://www.winjobs.ca/graphic-design-jobs-winnipeg.php
Graphic designers jobs in Winnipeg

This post is truly something uncommon and more data get-together by your site furthermore valuable. I need to some more data much appreciated http://www.worbuzz.com

Johnny Keller in 1903, when they were both hospitalized for diphtheria. They quickly developed a romantic relationship. After they were released from the hospital, Keller joined Williams as he traveled across Minnesota and Manitoba, Canada looking for work.
http://www.mylimousines.ca/toronto/ontario/wedding/limousines/
Toronto Wedding Limousines

I just got to this amazing site not long ago. I was actually captured with the piece of resources you have got here. Big thumbs up for making such wonderful blog page!
https://autoaccidentadviceblog.com/
Auto Accident Blog

The trials of the two most sensational murderers, Edward Gottschalk and Williams, even overlapped by a day. Gottschalk was notorious because of the gruesome way he killed his victims, and because he committed suicide before he could be executed by the state. Williams's murders were intriguing to readers because of his history with the victims.
http://www.vbrservers.com.br/
hospedagem de sites

I am really enjoying reading your well written articles. It looks like you spend a lot of effort and time on your blog. I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles. Keep up the good work.
http://nevadaattorney.biz/
nevada attorney

The trials of the two most sensational murderers, Edward Gottschalk and Williams, even overlapped by a day. Gottschalk was notorious because of the gruesome way he killed his victims, and because he committed suicide before he could be executed by the state. Williams's murders were intriguing to readers because of his history with the victims.

Samira Laser Clinic in Scarborough: Permanent Hair Removal for Men and Women
Samira Laser Clinic in Scarborough should be your only choice for laser hair removal. Our precision equipment carefully removes your hair while keeping your skin soft and glowing. We specialize in laser hair removal, facials and microdermabrasion.
http://www.mnopedia.org/event/execution-william-williams-1906

Gottschalk was notorious because of the gruesome way he killed his victims, and because he committed suicide before he could be executed by the state. Williams's murders were intriguing to readers because of his history with the victims.
<a title="http://www.tractariauto247.ro/" href="http://www.tractari auto">http://www.tractariauto247.ro/</a>

that alcohol and an argument made him temporarily insane. After hearing readings of his intimate letters with Johnny Keller, including one where Williams threatened the boy, the court rejected this claim. The jury found Williams guilty of first degree murder, which meant that he would be executed.
http://www.vividsaaga.com
Wedding photographers in Hyderabad

Good to become visiting your weblog again, it has been months for me. Nicely this article that i've been waited for so long. I will need this post to total my assignment in the college, and it has exact same topic together with your write-up. Thanks, good share.http://zomerfeesten.eu/mold-remediation-to-improve-the-health-of-your-pets/

Keller in 1903, when they were both hospitalized for diphtheria. They quickly developed a romantic relationship. After they were released from the hospital, Keller joined Williams as he traveled across Minnesota and Manitoba, Canada looking for work.
http://www.99medias.com/buy-instagram-followers-likes/
buy instagram followers cheap

I was superintendent of the old Ramsey County jail at 322 St. Peter st. in St. Paul, during the 1960's and 70's. The area where William Williams was hung was in the sub-basement of the jail that had been built 1900-1903. It was a historical spot, and Minnesota history buffs sometimes asked to see it.
During the Cold War this area was used to store civil defense supplies, and was to be used as a fallout shelter in case of war.
It was a really creepy place, dimly lit, dirt floor, old stone walls seeping with moisture.
The building was torn down in the end of the 70's. A newer part of the court house now covers the place of William's demise. I remember the history when I sometimes drive by.

The trials of the two most sensational murderers, Edward Gottschalk and Williams, even overlapped by a day. Gottschalk was notorious because of the gruesome way he killed his victims, and because he committed suicide before he could be executed by the state. Williams's murders were intriguing to readers because of his history with the victims.
http://www.sportsbetcapping.com
Nfl free picks 

They quickly developed a romantic relationship. After they were released from the hospital, Keller joined Williams as he traveled across Minnesota and Manitoba, Canada looking for work.
http://www.usedsmartmobiles.com
android mobiles